Davina Buff Jones: Compromised Evidence And The “Indeterminate” Hypothesis

Compromised evidence at the scene of the death of police officer Davina Buff Jones prevented a strong conclusion about the manner of death. In similar cases, adding the qualifier “indeterminate/insufficient evidence” to the list of hypotheses can bring attention to the fact the leading theory still possesses inconsistencies so severe that a confident judgment remains low.

Bald Head Island, North Carolina, police officer Davina Buff Jones died by gunshot on the night of 22 October 1999. However, the manner of her death–whether homicide or suicide–was obscured by a compromised forensic response. In the immediate aftermath, and for the next 14 years, one theory was replaced by another as authorities examined and then reexamined the evidence. As of today, the case remains open, if not actively worked, with the manner of death deemed “undetermined.”

---

Bald Head Island, North Carolina

Bald Head Island (historically, Smith Island), North Carolina, is an exclusive community located at the southernmost tip of the state, where the Cape Fear River meets the Atlantic Ocean. Public access is limited to ferry service or private vessel. No motorized vehicles or guns are allowed in the village, except among law enforcement officials. In 1999, there were around 150-200 year-round residents.

Davina Buff Jones

Davina “Dee” Buff Jones, 33, a native of Charlotte, North Carolina, was a relatively new recruit to the Bald Head Island Police Department, having been in the assignment just 10 months. It was a job she “fell into” more than sought after her second divorce.¹ It might have been an unusual choice considering her stature. She was described as “4 feet eleven inches in cowboy boots” and about 95 pounds.² She chose the Bald Head Island force after moving to nearby Oak Island around 1997 where her parents had retired. Colleagues in the department said she was known for her “volume and aggression”–the former due to being deaf in her right ear–but they “thought she had potential as an officer if she outgrew her emotional immaturity.”³

The reports about her rapport with villagers were mixed. Some said she was a “well-respected member of the force, “perfect for the department,” “very friendly,” “very professional.”⁴ But she was also the subject of complaints. She drove too fast, and was quick to ticket for minor offenses.⁵ After pulling her baton on three inebriated individuals, she was told to stick close to her partner to ensure a witness in the event of future issues.⁶

Around August 1999, Jones had filed a sexual harassment complaint against a paramedic,⁷ a circumstance that sat poorly with her superiors, in part because she didn’t follow her chain of command in the reporting.⁸ She believed the filing would lead to her being fired. On the night of the 22nd, Officer Jones spent a portion of her time at the station updating her resume.

In addition to workplace challenges, Jones struggled with mental health issues. Her physician diagnosed her with depression, for which she received treatment from 1994 to 1998, and later recommended psychiatric care.⁹ Records indicate she made 170 visits to a mental health clinic in 1997 alone.¹⁰ Several months before her death, she reportedly told superiors she was suffering from sleep deprivation.¹¹ Jones had attempted suicide twice in her youth–one apparently minor gesture and a second attempt that required medical intervention¹²–and friends recalled her saying that “…if not for her dogs…she would end her life.”¹³ She did not disclose her prior mental health treatment on her police employment application.¹⁴

22 October 1999

Twelve hours before her death, Jones reached out to her sister and chatted briefly with her six- and two-year-old nieces. Jones discussed a problem of a personal nature with her sister, which prompted her sister to ask, “Are you hopeless?” (“No”). Could she see “better days ahead” (“Yes”).¹⁵ Jones told her sister she’d been applying to other jobs.

Later that day, she stopped at a convenience store telling the cashier, “I wish I could think of a good excuse not to go to work today,” and that she “might just hide out that night.”¹⁶

On the ferry en route to her shift on Bald Head Island, Jones was “cheerful…the best mood I’ve seen her in a long time,” stated a fellow passenger.¹⁷

At 8PM, she ate dinner in the bar area of a local cafe. At 10:13PM, she and her partner were called back to the location to assist patrons with a ride home due to a missing golf cart. Apparently, the problem had been resolved when she and her partner arrived at 10:26PM because the area was empty. She asked two individuals on the porch of a grocery store located next to the cafe whether they had heard about a larceny in the area. They had not. Officer Jones sped away.

At 11:30PM, Jones reached out to a former live-in boyfriend with whom she’d recently had a “rocky” breakup.¹⁸ She’d telephoned him several times that day. Now her voice was “subdued.”¹⁹ She expressed regret about the circumstances of the separation, but said they would “always be friends.”²⁰ She ended the call with, “I’ll talk to you later.”²¹ Later, he expressed skepticism she had taken her own life.

Sometime between 11:30PM and midnight, her voice came over a somewhat distorted radio transmission to dispatch, “Show me out with three, standby…” indicating an interaction with three persons. Then, “There ain’t no reason to have a gun here on Bald Head Island, now put down the gun. Come on, do me a favor and put down the gun.”²² Officer Jones did not state her location. No other voices were heard on the recording. When her partner responded, he found Jones on the ground without a pulse.

Over the next hours, Bald Head Island Police Department, Brunswick County Sheriff’s Department, and State Bureau of Investigation officers, along with fire and ambulance services, helicopters, Coast Guard, and mainland law enforcement armed with assault rifles, converged on the location.

As authorities examined the scene, they documented little physical evidence to suggest the presence of another person. Investigators reported no additional footprints, no blood trail, and “no identifiable fingerprints on the weapon.”²³ A scuff of sand was noted on the right knee of Jones’s uniform, but aside from an “eraser-size nick” on her right wrist, no injuries indicative of a struggle were documented.²⁴ Examination of the body revealed that soot surrounding the wound indicated the muzzle had been pressed against her head when the weapon was fired. The bullet recovered from her skull matched ammunition carried in her service weapon, and a “trace of gunpowder residue was detected on the back of her right-hand fingerless bicycle glove.”²⁵ Testing also determined that the blood beneath Jones’s fingernails belonged to her.

Due to Jones’s wording of “out with three,” police interviewed three men operating a boat without lights in the vicinity. Their hands were tested for gunshot residue, which was negative. They were questioned and released.²⁶

Upon further investigation, police found no suicide note, which her father found out of character. She was a prolific communicator whose nature was to “‘[write] everything down…if Davina were planning to kill herself she would have left a 12-page letter explaining why.'”²⁷ At her home, police found a to-do list for the following day: getting a prescription filled, purchasing heartworm pills for her two dogs, and securing an estimate for work on her truck.²⁸

Within just a few days of her death, law enforcement told village officials there was no danger to the public. The mayor then issued a statement to villagers: “‘This is a terrible, tragic event, but the island is secure.'”²⁹

Mistakes Made

Significant forensic limitations were introduced during early processing that could not be reversed.

• In the confusion of a scene assessed as an active shooter, EMTs moved Jones’s body, letting the gun, which was in or under her right hand, fall to the ground. It was later removed from the scene, again, without understanding the criticality of marking the location for a later reconstruction of the night’s events.
• Jones’s body was transported by ambulance, but the vehicle, which may have contained additional forensic evidence, was unpreserved. Jones’s body itself was later left uncovered and unprotected.
• At the scene, the medical examiner identified the entry point of the bullet as to the side of Jones’s head behind her right ear. He later said that was due to the hair not being shaved and blood pooling in the area. At the autopsy, he found it was actually closer in the middle, back of her head. Yet the district attorney thought the original location closer to the ear was more accurate. Jones’s body was cremated so the precise location was never confirmed.
• The next morning, investigators found the bullet casing, photographed it, picked it up, and then replaced it on the ground for additional photos. However, they positioned it differently.
• A sketch at the scene captured a set of drag marks, but they were never explained.
• Twelve hours after the body was found, firefighters hosed down the area. Crime tape was removed, and the location was reopened to the public.

Law Enforcement Reviews, Decisions, and Actions

• Six weeks after her death, the Brunswick County district attorney (DA) classified Officer Jones’s death a suicide. “The evidence convinces me to a certainty beyond a reasonable doubt.”³⁰ He supported his thesis by stating no suspects had been identified; the autopsy was consistent with a suicide; there was no evidence of a struggle; the 911 tape did not contain additional voices; and facts uncovered about Officer Jones’s personal life supported the possibility of suicide.³¹

• On 19 July 2004, the North Carolina Industrial Commission, an agency charged with administering the state’s worker’s compensation act, called the case a homicide and ordered $25,000 to be paid to Jones’s estate.³² In the ruling, the hearing officer wrote, “‘The disturbance of the site where the decedent’s body was found and the disturbance and contamination of the crime scene make it impossible to make a definitive showing that the manner of death was suicide.'”³³

• In 2005, an appeal from the state attorney general’s office to the North Carolina Industrial Commission to overturn the $25,000 benefit was rejected. At the same time, the Commission increased the compensation amount from $25,000 to $50,000.

• In February 2006, the US Department of Justice, Public Safety Officers’ Benefits Office, awarded the family $146,949. The department had previously denied the family benefits, but reversed their decision after a hearing “based on new evidence.”³⁴ The office did not elaborate on the reasoning behind the reversal.

• In June 2006, the State Bureau of Investigation concluded a one-year review of the original case with the finding of suicide unchanged.³⁵ “‘The totality of circumstances, ranging from her mental state to the facts at the scene, are more consistent to a staged event by Jones resulting in her death.'”³⁶

• In December 2013, a new DA reclassified Jones’s death as “undetermined.” The reclassification stemmed from a review by four retired FBI agents who had reviewed the case but who could not come to a consensus, along with the previous contradictory decisions by the former DA and Industrial Commission. The new DA advised, “‘Evidence in this case supports two divergent theories about the cause of death.'”³⁷

Analysis

The two most prominent hypotheses in the case were suicide or homicide. Accident was added to ensure rigor. Due to the circumstances of the case, a qualifier was also added to the hypotheses list: “indeterminate/insufficient evidence to determine manner of death.”

H1: Suicide

H2: Accidental/self-caused shooting

H3: Homicide by unknown offender

H4: Indeterminate / insufficient evidence to determine manner of death

The four hypotheses and a 12-item set of evidence was analyzed using the Analysis of Competing Hypotheses first by the analyst and then by large language models ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Grok.

As expected, the accidental death hypothesis was effectively eliminated, with homicide also receiving little support. Suicide proved more resilient and emerged as the strongest substantive explanation. However, the analysis ultimately favored H4, indeterminate/insufficient evidence. While the physical evidence generally aligned with suicide, the severely compromised crime scene, unresolved investigative questions, and anomalous final dispatch transmission (“out with three…”) prevented a confident determination of the manner of death.

Postscript

The Davina Buff Jones case illustrates the value of including an “indeterminate/insufficient evidence” hypothesis to some ACH matrices. It is not an explanation about what happened; it describes the state of the evidence. In cases involving compromised forensics, unresolved investigative questions, or conflicting interpretations, an indeterminate hypothesis helps guard against false certainty. Rather than forcing the analyst to choose the hypothesis with the fewest inconsistencies, it provides a structured means of recognizing that the available evidence may simply be inadequate to support a confident judgment.

---

Footnotes

1. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002. ↩︎
2. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002. ↩︎
3. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002. ↩︎
4. Cece Von Kolnitz, “‘You don’t think it will happen here’; Slaying shatters peace of exclusive Bald Head,” StarNews, 25 October 1999. ↩︎
5. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002. ↩︎
6. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002. ↩︎
7. Ken Little, “Officer’s death still leaves questions–Hearing concludes with testimony from Jones’ friends,” StarNews, 25 October 2003. ↩︎
8. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002. ↩︎
9. Erin Zureick, “DA to relook at case of island officer found dead,” StarNews, 18 May 2011. ↩︎
10. Ken Little, “Hearing begins on Bald Head case — Witness: Officer sought treatment for depression,” StarNews, 24 October 2003. ↩︎
11. Ken Little, “Hearing begins on Bald Head case–Witness: Officer sought treatment for depression,” StarNews, 24 October 2003. ↩︎
12. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002. ↩︎
13. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002. ↩︎
14. Ken Little, “Hearing begins on Bald Head case — Witness: Officer sought treatment for depression,” StarNews, 24 October 2003. ↩︎
15. Cece Von Kolnitz and Victoria Cherrie, “Evidence builds case for suicide; Bald Head officer’s life is described as troubled,” StarNews, 5 November 1999. ↩︎
16. Cece Von Kolnitz and Victoria Cherrie, “Evidence builds case for suicide; Bald Head officer’s life is described as troubled,” StarNews, 5 November 1999. ↩︎
17. Cece Von Kolnitz and Victoria Cherrie, “Evidence builds case for suicide; Bald Head officer’s life is described as troubled,” StarNews, 5 November 1999. ↩︎
18. Ken Little, “Officer’s death still leaves questions–Hearing concludes with testimony from Jones’ friends,” StarNews, 25 October 2003. ↩︎
19. Ken Little, “Officer’s death still leaves questions–Hearing concludes with testimony from Jones’ friends,” StarNews, 25 October 2003. ↩︎
20. Ken Little, “Officer’s death still leaves questions–Hearing concludes with testimony from Jones’ friends,” StarNews, 25 October 2003. ↩︎
21. Ken Little, “Officer’s death still leaves questions–Hearing concludes with testimony from Jones’ friends,” StarNews, 25 October 2003. ↩︎
22. Cece Von Kolnitz, “‘There ain’t no reason to have a gun here’; Bald Head officer met 3 people, then was slain,” 26 October 1999. ↩︎
23. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002. ↩︎
24. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002.  ↩︎
25. Anna Griffin, “Bald Head Island Mystery–Questions linger about who fired the shot that killed a rookie police officer murder or suicide?” Charlotte Observer, 2 June 2002. ↩︎
26. Cece Von Kolnitz and Victoria Cherrie, “Evidence builds case for suicide; Bald Head officer’s life is described as troubled,” StarNews, 5 November 1999. ↩︎
27. Cece Von Kolnitz, “Bald Head: Officer’s case not closed for all: Questions left for many after Davina Jones’ death,” StarNews, 22 May 2000. ↩︎
28. Cece Von Kolnitz, “Bald Head: Officer’s case not closed for all: Questions left for many after Davina Jones’ death,” StarNews, 22 May 2000. ↩︎
29. Cece Von Kolnitz, “‘There ain’t no reason to have a gun here’; Bald Head officer met 3 people, then was slain,” 26 October 1999. ↩︎
30. No author provided, “Prosecutor lists reasons for conclusion,” StarNews, 10 December 1999. ↩︎
31. No author provided, “Prosecutor lists reasons for conclusion,” StarNews, 10 December 1999. ↩︎
32. Ken Little, “Commission: Officer’s death not a suicide,” StarNews, 21 July 2004. ↩︎
33. Ken Little, “Commission: Officer’s death not a suicide,” StarNews, 21 July 2004. ↩︎
34. Veronica Gonzalez, “Benefits awarded to officer’s family,” StarNews, 4 February 2006. ↩︎
35. Ken Little, “SBI reinforces suicide ruling in officer death–Father maintains daughter was slain on Bald Head Island in ’99,” StarNews, 3 June 2006. ↩︎
36. Erin Zureick, “DA to relook at case of island officer found dead,” StarNews, 18 May 2011. ↩︎
37. Sam Hickman, “Cause of death in 1999 Bald Head officer shooting,” The Brunswick Beacon, 17 December 2013. ↩︎